Herb, Nut, and Onion Bread

"Herb Nut & Onion Bread." from Make It Like a Man! herb, nut, and onion bread

This bread has a surprisingly light and refined texture for such a substantial and flavorful loaf. Its scent is so appetizing and its flavor is as fresh as a vegetable garden at the height of summer. It would beautifully compliment a hearty sandwich or a sharp cheese. It makes fantastic toast and is great with eggs and thick-cut bacon.

Makes 2 loaves

This Herb, Nut, and Onion Bread recipe uses a pre-fermentation technique that helps give it flavor and substance.

Specifically, it uses a sponge (or, to hit the nail right on the head, a poolish), which has the added benefit of endowing the bread with a longer shelf life. It also includes nut meal. Although you can buy nut meal, a coffee grinder will turn walnuts into a fine meal in a mere couple of seconds. Be careful; a couple more seconds and the meal will start turning to a paste.

Sponge Ingredients

½ cup spring water
½ tsp active dry yeast (from one ¼-oz packet)
¾ cup white bread flour

Sponge Directions

"Herb, Nut, and Onion Bread," from Make It Like a Man!

Warm the water, but don’t let it get hot.[1] You can do this by either nuking it, or by mixing cold and hot water until you’ve arrived at the right temperature. Put the water in a small bowl and sprinkle the yeast on top. Let it sit for 1 minute, then stir. Add the flour and stir just until blended. Then, stir it vigorously for 100 strokes. (If you’re super hard-ass, do it with your non-dominant arm.) When you’re done, it should be smooth, yet a bit granular, and quite thick – kind of like a very thick milk shake, except that it will also be very sticky. It should look something like a batter, not like dough. Add water to achieve this consistency, if needed. Scrape down the sides with a spatula. Place a damp cloth or plastic wrap over it, and let it sit in a warm spot[2] for anywhere from 2 to 10 hours. It should significantly increase in volume, smell yeasty or beer-like, and appear disturbingly bubbly.

Dough Ingredients

1½ cups (loosely packed) fresh thyme leaves
1½ cups (loosely packed) fresh oregano leaves
6 oz walnuts
3 oz pecans
2 cups white bread flour
2 Tbs minced, dried onion
1¼ cups sour cream, room temperature
1½ cups spring water, room temperature
The rest of the packet of active dry yeast
1 Tbs salt
1 Tbs honey
1 tsp olive oil
3½ cups[3] light wheat flour[4]

Dough Directions

Adding the Special Ingredients:

Chop the herbs; set aside. Grind half of the walnuts into a fine meal. In a medium mixing bowl, whisk the meal with the white flour. Set aside. Chop the remaining walnuts and all of the pecans to pieces approximately the size of popcorn kernels. Scrape the sponge into a large mixing bowl. Add herbs, chopped nuts, onion, sour cream, yeast, salt, and honey. Stir thoroughly, and make an effort to break up the sponge. Add the nut-meal mixture, and stir to combine thoroughly.

Adding the Flour:

Begin adding flour by heaping half-cupsful, stirring after each. Quite soon, it will become too difficult to stir. At that point, scrape it onto a floured surface and continue adding successively smaller amounts of flour, mixing it together with a bench scraper and your hands. Take your time and don’t work too hard. The dough wants to incorporate the flour, and you’re just assisting it. In time, it will become dense enough that you can knead it. Continue kneading and adding flour until the dough is no longer sticky. Note that it will be somewhat tacky, but it will not actually stick to your hands or the counter. Form the dough into a loose ball.

When you first begin to add flour, you add relatively large amounts, and it incorporates quickly. As the process moves along, it takes longer and longer to incorporate the flour, and you add less and less of it each time. Indeed, the last couple flour additions might be a scant ¼-cup at the most.

Kneading is a cyclical process: the dough feels sticky, so you add some flour. That eliminates the stickiness, so you continue to knead … but eventually the dough feel sticky again. Each time you repeat this cycle, the amount of time that you can knead the dough before it becomes sticky increases.

Clean out and dry the mixing bowl. Then, oil it lightly. Place the dough in the bowl, then remove it from the bowl, turn it upside down, and place it back in the bowl. This gets oil all over the dough. Cover the bowl with a damp towel or plastic wrap, and let it sit until the dough increases significantly in volume and passes the finger test. You can let his happen in the fridge overnight. In that case, the dough has to come toward room temperature before proceeding.[5]

Punch the dough down, shape it back into a ball, cover the bowl back up, and let it rest for 30 minutes.

"Herb, Nut, and Onion Bread," from Make It Like a Man!

Gently move the dough to a lightly floured surface. Divide it in half, and form each half into whatever final shape you desire, or put them into buttered bread pans.[6] Cover them with oiled plastic wrap and let them rise until they substantially clear the edges of the pans, or until, once again, they pass the dreaded finger test (which is different for the 2nd rise).

Preheat the oven to 450°F. Place a shallow dish (or a pie plate) of water in the bottom of the oven.[7] Bake the loaves for 15-20 minutes, then lower the temperature to 400°F and continue to bake for 15-20 minutes more. The finished loaves should be richly browned. Test the loaves by removing them from the pan and tapping them on the bottom. They should sound hollow. If they need more time, place them back into the oven, in or out of the pan. Let them cool on a rack, out of the pan. The inside of the bread will continue to cook for several minutes as it rests on the rack. Wait until the loaf feels completely room temperature before slicing into it.


Could you make Herb, Nut, and Onion Bread in a stand mixer? Of course you could. The process I use for 8-Grain White Bread would work just fine if you have a large-size mixer. For a standard-size mixer, cut this recipe in half and make one loaf at a time. If you have the right space for it, though, making bread by hand is a kind of a deep-down good experience. You need a surface that is a couple inches lower than your waist, so that you can easily leverage the weight of your upper body onto your hands while keeping your elbows relatively straight. Lean into the dough instead of relying exclusively on muscle power. Kneading dough can be therapeutic and meditative rather than just a lot of work. With your hands in the dough, you’re also more likely to add just the right amount of flour.

[2] Warm Spot: Normally, this means, in part, a place where there is no draft. A draft can cause dough to rise unevenly. The sponge won’t care much about this. Temperature, however, will affect the amount of time that it takes for your sponge or dough to develop. Attempting to create an artificially warm environment – short of owning a proofing oven – works, but my best loaves have never been produced that way. If my house has spots that are warmer than others – like upstairs in summer – I’ll make use of them. Otherwise, I’ll just accept the ambient temperature of some out-of-the-way place that is not near a window, a heating vent, or any other source of heating/cooling.
"Hazy Winter," from Make It Like a Man! herb, nut, and onion bread

I mean this kind of cool

"Space House," from Today's Photo via Make It Like a Man! herb, nut, and onion bread

I don’t mean kind of cool

[5] Refrigerated Dough: At refrigerator temperature, the finger test may not be reliable. Don’t underestimate how long it might take to bring refrigerated dough close to room temperature, especially if your house is cool.
[7] Water in Oven: There are many good reasons for this, which you can read about, here. Here’s one way to do it: just before preheating the oven, place an empty pie plate on the lower rack and place a kettle of water on the stove to boil. Next, you’re going to create some steam and try to trap it in the oven, so you’ll have to work quickly. As soon as you’re ready to put the bread into the oven, quickly pour a lot of water into the pie plate, getting it roughly half full. Don’t worry about splashing water all over your oven; that’s fine so long as you don’t splash the oven’s light bulb. (If you’re not using a bread stone, you can just pour the water right through the upper rack.) Then, as quickly as you can, but without agitating the dough, slide the bread into the oven and shut the door. I do this recklessly, with water in one hand and bread in the other. More prudent people pull the bottom rack out a bit, put the bread on the top rack, pour in the water, and slide in the rack.

Image creds: hover over image to reveal source. If an image has a green caption, hover over it. Click to jump to or toward source.You might notice that we’ve placed this bread in our “entertaining” category, and maybe you’re wondering about that, because you’re pretty sure you’ve never been entertained by a loaf of bread before. Well, check out that category to see how we define it. If you showed up to a potluck with one of these babies – especially if you free-formed the loaf rather than bread-panning it – believe me, you would Rihanna the hell out of that party.

Banana Cream Pie Bars
Bourgeois Pig

3 thoughts on “Herb, Nut, and Onion Bread

    • I made this bread with what I happened to have on hand that day, but it turned out to be one of those things that comes out so well, I knew right away I’d better jot it down. Every time I make it, I want to add more and more and more herbs. If you make it, I’d be curious to know if you think it has enough herbs yet!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


CommentLuv badge

Optionally add an image (JPEG only)