Molten Chocolate Lava Cake:
Ooey, Gooey, and Double-Baked

"Molten Chocolate Lava Cake," from Make It Like a Man!

This week, we reviewed a recipe for a molten lava chocolate cake from Sarah Jampel at Food 52.

This is a profoundly chocolate cake. As fantastic as its flavor is, its texture is also marvelous – incredibly rich, yet its density is modulated by an equal degree of delicacy. The molten chocolate is luxurious and the cake melts in your mouth – what am I saying? It melts before it even hits your mouth. The directions work exactly as advertised. It’s also, as scratch cakes go, fairly easy. This recipe really drills it home that the molten part of a molten chocolate lava cake is simply under-baked batter. But it’s a flourless cake, which is why it works. The recipe comes from Food 52, adapted from a recipe at Dana Treat, which is in turn adapted from a recipe at Food and Wine. And now I’m adding my unholy link to that chain.

What you need for one 9-inch, (single-layer) cake

8 oz. bittersweet or semisweet chocolate, coarsely chopped
8 oz. unsalted butter (1/2 pound, or 2 sticks)
2 1/2 oz. unsweetened cocoa powder (3/4 cup)
Pinch of salt
12.25 oz. eggs, separated (from 7 large eggs)
9.5 oz. sugar (1 1/3 cups) 

Abbreviated Directions (for full directions, see Food 52)

Melt chocolate and butter, whisk in cocoa and salt. Preheat. Beat yolks and half the sugar, 3 minutes, med-high. Whip whites, beat in remaining sugar: very stiff. Fold in chocolate, then whites. Reserve 2 cups (refrigerate). Bake in a buttered 9″ springform for 25 at 350°F. Cool completely. (Can be kept, refrigerated.) Remove collar. Spread batter. (Replace collar.) Bake 15 at 400°F. Cool to warm.

"Molten Chocolate Lava Cake," from Make It Like a Man!

Notes:
  • If your pan is the type with a pedestal base, consider the parchment optional. If your pan is the more common type – with a small lip around the base – parchment is optional if you intend to serve the cake on the base, but you’ll need it if you want to remove the cake to a plate.
  • Seven eggs yolks should weigh 5.25 oz. If yours weigh less, add another yolk and/or supplement with mayo. Seven egg whites should weigh 7 oz. Mine weighed 8 3/8, and I went with it – all good.
  • If you’re using a stand mixer and have only one bowl, scrape the beaten yolks into a large mixing bowl, then wash out the stand mixer’s bowl with hot, hot water so that no trace of the yolk remains.
  • Very stiff beaten whites look like marshmallow cream. The more volume, the better.
  • Two generous cups of batter weighs about 10 oz. Do not – I repeat, do not – taste this cake batter if you have no sense of discipline. It is so delicious that you will eat it in its entirety and wind up with no cake to show for the effort.
  • The cake will crack, and while cooling it will fall. It will look like a spectacular fail, and you may worry that you haven’t saved enough batter to fill the crater. Fret not; you have. If you don’t like the look of the cracker-like ridge, carefully remove it – but I love the way it looks. This is not a typical-looking cake – it looks like a lava flow!
  • I like the collar on when I rebake the cake. I find this reduces the possibility of blackened edges.
  • Want to take this to a dinner party? When you’re ready to leave, spread the reserved batter, replace the collar if you removed it, cover with foil. You’ll need to use your host’s oven only for a few minutes between dinner and dessert.
  • Leftover cake is easy to cut straight from the fridge. Pop it in the microwave for 1-2 minutes (depending on how large a piece) at 30% power. This will get it warm/hot and re-moltenize the ooey-gooey. It’s quite good. Its flavor may have lost a slight edge in terms of nuance, but the texture seems surprisingly more exquisite.
"Ooey, Gooey, Chocolate Cake," from Food 52, via Make It Like a Man! Molten Chocolate Lava Cake

Credit: Food 52

In the photos that accompany the Food 52 post, the molten part of the cake appears to be very slowly oozing its way toward the plate. I was able to get the same effect (setting aside my flagrant disregard for art direction), only by letting the cake cool to the point that it was just a handful of degrees above body temperature. This type of cake is often served hot, in which case in this form, there’s no way you’d get decent-looking wedge shape. The molten chocolate will pool on the plate. That is probably why these kinds of cakes are usually brought to you in single-serving ramekins. However, I tried this cake over and over again, at every temperature. (Oh, the things I do for you, The Internet.) This cake absolutely rules when warm rather than hot – in the form that it’s pictured here. It’s really good hot, but it’s a life-changing experience when just warm enough to slowly ooze.

Brava, Sarah 5 out of 5 stars (5 / 5)

If you’d like to consider a version of this cake whose molten center is ganache instead of batter, check this out. While I contend that Ooey, Gooey batter is probably more delicious than a ganache, I’m eager to try the ganache.

"Molten Chocolate Lava Cake," from Make It Like a Man!

Molten Chocolate Lava Cake is delicious, but there are many cakes deserving of your love.

"Cinna-Choco-Cakeughnut," from Make It Like a Man! Molten Chocolate Lava Cake

Cakeughnut

"Chocolate Stout Cake," from Make It Like a Man! Molten Chocolate Lava Cake

Chocolate

"Apple Cake Slider," from Make It Like a Man! Molten Chocolate Lava Cake

Apple

Doughnut Cake, from Make It Like a Man! Molten Chocolate Lava Cake

More Cakes

Large Blog Image

Chocolate Birthday Baileys Surprise Cake
Truffle and Herb Ricotta Cheesecake

23 thoughts on “Molten Chocolate Lava Cake:
Ooey, Gooey, and Double-Baked

    • Oh! If you have a recipe for it that you really love, I’d be curious to see it.

  1. So I’m confused a bit here, Jeff. You mention leftover cake. I don’t understand that concept. But what I do understand is ooey, gooey melty chocolate deliciousness…and this cake seems to have all of those required elements. Well done!
    David @ Spiced recently posted…Mexican Style Hummus

    • Strange, I know, but this cake has such a rich texture, that I found one medium slice to be quite enough. (Would I ever say such a thing about lemon? Wait a minute … is there a molten lemon cake???)

    • I was tempted to serve the whole batch of batter unbaked. In fact, I just may sometime.

    • I’m still baking. I don’t know what got into me. Maybe it’s because I cleaned my oven recently, and now I need to get it filthy again. Maybe I should bake a pie that boils over and end this madness!

  2. Oh my gosh this makes my chocolate loving heart go pitter patter! I tend to overbake my lava cakes so there isn’t any lava! You’ve inspired me to try again.
    Julie recently posted…Chicken Gyro Recipe

  3. This is a really unusual cake (which is odd to say about a lava cake). I’ll give it a try the next time the chocolate bug bites. GREG

    • It is unusual; that’s what I liked about it. It’s really, really good!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Website

CommentLuv badge